The Thing Remastered Review: Okay, Not Great – A Complete Remake Would Have Been Better

The remaster improves some things over the base game but its nothing to rave about.

SCORE BREAKDOWN

Gameplay
7
Visuals
7
Mechanics
7
Sound
7
Replay Value
7

Latest news

The Thing: Remastered brings back the cult classic 2002 game with improved visuals and quality-of-life updates, faithfully preserving its unique blend of trust, paranoia, and horror-action gameplay. Acting as a sequel to John Carpenter’s 1982 film, the game immerses players in an unsettling atmosphere as Captain Blake, leading a squad against shape-shifting alien threats.

We played the game on PC via Steam and getting quick to the point- it was fun. While there was nothing groundbreaking, we enjoyed our time with the game even though it is nothing more than a polish over the original. We would have preferred a remake to take advantage of modern day hardware but perhaps PC players will take advantage of the modding community to experience the game with even more enhancements. However, if you have played this game before and didnt care for it or managed to play it recently somehow, there’s little reason to go back for the price of $30.00 USD.

Its standout mechanic—managing squad trust and fear—creates moments of tension and unpredictability, but its execution is limited by rigid scripting and outdated design constraints. Nightdive Studios has done commendable work in restoring the game, improving visuals and some mechanics, but the fundamental flaws of the original still remain.

The Thing: Remastered | Nightdive Studios

While the updated visuals and smoother controls enhance the experience, the game’s potential is hampered by predetermined transformations and linear level design that undermine its ambitious squad dynamics. Trust and paranoia mechanics initially shine but lose impact as gameplay devolves into a standard run-and-gun shooter.

Despite its shortcomings, The Thing: Remastered remains a valuable piece of game preservation, reminding players of the innovative but imperfect attempt to translate the film’s dread into a video game. However, a full remake could have allowed the game’s unique systems to flourish more dynamically, leaving this remaster as a compelling yet flawed homage to its predecessor.

The Thing: Remastered | Nightdive Studios

I recall playing the 2002 original for PS2 somewhat recently and it still held up. Sure, there were some bugs and odd interactions with the environment that crept up here and there but it was still a fun time. This remaster is nothing more than a slight improvement on the original and that no doubt will please a handful of fans who were looking for some minor enhancements to improve the player experience but its clear this game deserved a complete remake rather than remaster. For a little perspective, the remaster looks like it improved textures to be worthy enough of the PS3 and that may satisfy some but we don’t expect this game to ignite a huge new fanbase or anything.

A remake of the original would have been a godsend and maybe this remaster is enough of an open door to keep that idea in consideration but if anything, we expect the PC port of the remaster to at least keep a window open for possible mods that could push the experience over the edge into greatness.

Still, if you played the original recently, whether on classic hardware or via emulation, you may not immediately want to jump into the remaster right away since it doesn’t change enough to be worthy of an immediate replay. But at $30, that is for you to decide.

TL;DR

If you managed to play the original through some means, most likely through emulation, you may appreciate a remaster's attempts at some bug fixes and improved visuals but you might find the gameplay to feel all too familiar. While the game will reach some fans and new players who missed out on the original, it does little in the ways of anything groundbreaking. Still, its a decent game overall and is worth picking up at the base price of $30 USD if you have the extra cash. Otherwise, you may find more value in waiting for a sale in the not too distant future.

Want us to review something cool? Email us! news@geekoutpost.com

Marc
Marc
Marc is the Editor in Chief for Geek Outpost. If you have an inside scoop you want to share, you can email him at marc@geekoutpost.com. He prefers Crocs for their style over their comfort.

CHECK 'EM OUT
MORE REVIEWS

TV 14 [as] Saturdays at 12a ET

If you managed to play the original through some means, most likely through emulation, you may appreciate a remaster's attempts at some bug fixes and improved visuals but you might find the gameplay to feel all too familiar. While the game will reach some fans and new players who missed out on the original, it does little in the ways of anything groundbreaking. Still, its a decent game overall and is worth picking up at the base price of $30 USD if you have the extra cash. Otherwise, you may find more value in waiting for a sale in the not too distant future. The Thing Remastered Review: Okay, Not Great - A Complete Remake Would Have Been Better